CocktailsCharles Sieg
Lake House Old Fashioned, served in a rocks glass

All recipes

Lake House Old Fashioned

Rye chilled in the shaker, then strained over Luxardo cherries into a bitters-coated glass with an orange peel.

Glass
Rocks glass
Method
Swirled with ice in the shaker
Served
Neat, no ice
Garnish
1 strip of orange peel

Ingredients

Make

1 drink, as written.

  • 2 oz rye whiskeyBulleit Rye, or any of the WhistlePig whiskeys
  • 1 tsp simple syrup
  • 3 to 4 dashes Angostura bittersAbout Angostura bitters
  • 1 strip of orange peel
  • 3 to 4 Luxardo cherries on a skewer
  • A few drops of the Luxardo syrup (optional)

In a rocks glass

Method

  1. In the empty shaker, add the rye and the simple syrup.
  2. Fill the shaker at least halfway with ice, swirl it a few times, and let it sit.
  3. Add the bitters to the rocks glass. Tilt the glass and rotate it to coat the inside with the bitters.
  4. Peel a strip off the orange. Rub the peel around the rim of the glass and leave it in the glass.
  5. Put 3 or 4 cherries on a skewer and set the skewer in the glass.
  6. Strain the chilled whiskey over the cherries and into the glass.
  7. Consider adding a few drops of the Luxardo syrup for more flavor.

From my notes

  • I’m trying out a tiny spray bottle to spritz the bitters onto the glass instead.
  • Gear: a rocks glass, a peeler, a cocktail shaker, 4 or 4½ inch skewers, and lots of ice.